Home Page - Sweet Andy's Cookies
Call in Orders @ 631-288-2688    Follow us on    Follow us on Twitter   Sweet Andys on Instagram
Cookie Reviews

Hi Andy, I checked you in at the YFC golf outing yesterday 8/1 that my husband was running. It wasn’t long before the other 2 ladies and I just had to open a package. We tried the triple chip. WOW. Your cookies were (and still are!) the best I have EVER eaten….and I am a home baker! Jack and my family have nearly devoured the two bags we brought home and I can’t wait to find them in a store near us. Congratulations on a terriffic product and a big THANK YOU for bringing them to Mill River for the golf outing.
Becky….for the whole Crabtree family!

Sweet Andy's cookies are worth competing with Tates... because they are much less thin dark and crunchy.. and are instead lighter, softer but good in their own right .. and are absolutely delicious. I took some home last summer when they were starting out from the Westhampton farmers market / fair and they were an absolute hit.

Sweet Andy's is not going anywhere - they will last because they are consistantly better looking than the main cookies in a bag out here and really are better.

To propertly enjoy these cookies - you need to buy at least two bags. 5 cookies is not realistic when bringing somewhere.
Tracy K C


These cookies are absolutely amazing!!! I bought them at the Montauk Thursday
Farmers Market and can’t wait to buy some more!

the best cookies this side of the Mississippi!


PO Box 1749 136 Old Riverhead Road
Westhampton Beach, NY 11978 631-288-2688